SCHOOL | LOCATION | DIVISION |
| Clarke University | Dubuque, IA | NAIA |
| Concordia University of Chicago | River Forest, IL | Division III |
| Spalding University | Louisville, KY | Division III |
| Walsh University | North Canton, OH | Division II |
| North Central College | Naperville, IL | Division III |
| Cornell College | Mt. Vernon, IA | Division III |
| Marietta College | Marietta, OH | Division III |
| Columbia College | Columbia, MO | NAIA |
| Concordia University - Wisconsin | Moquon, WI | Division III |
| Wittenberg University | Springfield, OH | Division III |
| Hiram College | Hiram, OH | Division III |
| Ohio Northern University | Ada, OH | Division III |
| Trine University | Angola, IN | Division III |
| Tusculum University | Greeneville, TN | Division II |
| Thomas More University | Crestview Hills, KY | Division II |
| College of Wooster | Wooster, OH | Division III |
| Concordia University - Ann Arbor | Ann Arbor, MI | NAIA |
| Hanover College | Hanover, IN | Division III |
| Milwaukee School of Engineering | Milwaukee, WI | Division III |
| Muskingum University | New Concord, OH | Division IIII |
| St. Ambrose University | Davenport, IA | NAIA |
| Thomas More University | Crestview Hills, KY | Division II |
| St. Andrews University | Laurinburg, NC | NAIA |
| Otterbein University | Westerville, OH | Division III |
| Franciscan University | Steubenville, OH | Division III |
| LaRoche University | Pittsburgh, PA | Division III |
| Thiel College | Greenville, PA | Division III |
| Bethany College | Bethany, WV | Division III |
| Taylor University | Upland, IN | Division II |